Agent profile image in chat bubble
Agent profile image in chat header

Susan Maryanski

Operator | Opulent Living | Keller Williams City Life

Agent profile image in message

71 Bartholdi Ave , Butler Boro, NJ 07405
$850,000
Est. Payment: $4,377.52/mo
12 Bed
5.5 Bath
0 Sqft
Status: Active | Days on site: 93
Get Pre-Qualified
4312 - 302038
By proceeding and clicking the sign up button, you consent to receive calls and texts (SMS/MMS) including marketing and promotional communications, from Susan Maryanski, its affiliates, and agents or vendors acting on their behalf. These communications may be delivered using an automatic telephone dialing system or by using an artificial or prerecorded voice. Message and data rates may apply. To opt out of text messages, reply STOP. Your consent is not required as a condition of any purchase. By continuing, you also agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Agent profile image
Susan Maryanski
Operator

House Description

A truly rare opportunity awaits with this former rectory, offering an extraordinary combination of space, character, and endless possibilities. Rich in history & filled with architectural charm, this one-of-a-kind property provides an impressive layout designed to accommodate a variety of uses. The first floor welcomes you with a gracious entry foyer leading to expansive living and dining room, a large eat in kitchen complete with an oversized pantry, two bedrooms, a full bath, and a spacious family room. Adding to the home's unique appeal is a private chapel, preserving the property's distinctive heritage & creating a remarkable space unlike anything else on the market. The second floor offers exceptional living quarters: five generously sized bedroom suites, each with its own attached sitting area. For those seeking additional sleeping accommodations, the existing layout presents the potential to create up to ten bedrooms by enclosing the sitting areas. Three full bathrooms serve this level. On the third floor you'll find a large unfinished attic with so much potential for storage, expansion, or finishing. The lower level is equally impressive, featuring 8 foot ceilings, a large open recreation room, a summer kitchen, laundry area, and numerous storage rooms. Whether you're seeking a spacious private residence, institutional use, or a property with redevelopment potential, this remarkable property offers unmatched size, flexibility, & opportunity.

Highlights

Listed by CHERILYN R. VENTOLA , MP HOWARD HANNA RAND REALTY , 973-694-6500. Garden State MLS

Property Type

Residential

Lot/Acreage
0.51

Year Built

4195

County

Morris

Listing ID

4032345

Questions about this listing?

Contact Agent

Interior Features

Bedrooms and Bathrooms
  • Bedrooms:12
  • Bathrooms:5.5
  • Full Bathrooms:5
  • 1/2 Bathrooms:1
Appliances:Carbon Monoxide Detector
Floor:Carpeting,Tile,Wood
Basement:Finished,Full
Water:Public Water

Exterior Features

Lot:Corner
Lot Dimensions:60X153
Roof:Asphalt Shingle
Others:
  • Additional:Deck, Patio, Stone, Driveway-Exclusive
Sewer:Public Sewer
Principal Interest
$4,378
Taxes
$542

Home Price

$850,000

Loan Details

30 yrs
6.677%

Down Payment

20%
$170,000
All calculations are estimates and provided by Blueroof360. Today’s Rates provided by Blueroof360. Information and interactive calculators are made available to you only as self-help tools for your independent use and are not intended to provide investment or tax advice. We cannot and do not guarantee their applicability or accuracy in regards to your individual circumstances. All examples are hypothetical and are for illustrative purposes. We encourage you to seek personalized advice from qualified professionals regarding all personal finance issues.
Monthly Price:
$4,377.52

Principal

Taxes

Principal Taxes HOA Total
Monthly $4,377.52 $541.88 $0.00 $4,919.40
Yearly $52,530.25 $6,502.50 $0.00 $59,032.75
Total $1,575,907.53 $195,075.00 $0.00 $1,770,982.53

Today's Rates

30 Year

6.68%

20 Year

6.59%

15 Year

6.04%

Never Miss a Property

Be the first to know when a property hits the market.

Current Listings

Last 30 Days
N/A
Sep 2026

Average Price

All Price Ranges
N/A
Sep 2026

Average Days on Market

All Price Ranges
N/A
Sep 2026
Market insight data is pulled from the same city as the listing being viewed (Butler Boro, NJ).

The schools listed are within a 2-mile radius of the property; however, attendance is not guaranteed. Please contact the local school district to confirm zoning and enrollment options.

Information provided by Garden State MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate.

IDX service by Blueroof 360

Data last updated: 2026-09-05T10:59:24.000Z

© 2026 Garden State MLS